The church was destroyed in the Great Chicago Fire of 1871, but was quickly rebuilt through the hard work and dedication of the congregation. In 1898, St. Pauls moved to its Lincoln Park location.

When fire destroyed the church building on Christmas night in 1955, members resolved to rebuild and remain in the city, reaffirming Saint Pauls commitment to serve the urban community. During the 1960s and '70s, Saint Pauls, along with all city churches, felt the impact of urban renewal and the movement of members to the suburbs. The 1,500-member congregation was reduced to approximately 500 members by 1980. There was a great deal of concern about the future of the church during those two decades, but the committed congregation worked hard to maintain the church building; retain pastoral, music, office and maintenance staff; offer education and social programs; and carry out benevolence work.

Their efforts were rewarded with renewal during the 1980s, as the congregation more than doubled in size again and chose as its motto the phrase "Making a Joyful Sound in the City." The motto reflects the history of the congregation as well as its current mission.

Making a Joyful Sound in the City, a book by Saint Pauls Senior Pastor Tom Henry, tells the inspiring story of this congregation's life in Chicago from 1843 to its 150th anniversary. Copies of this hardbound commemorative edition, which is illustrated with historical photos, are $20 each. For details, call the Church office at 773-348-3829.